Seven rules for considering hearsay evidence in a disciplinary enquiry
By general definition, 'hearsay' is understood as being information that canno't really be proven. It's often heard by someone else and so can easily amount to nothing more than rumours.
For example, hearsay can be when person A heard from person B that pPerson C did something.
But hearsay is presented as a form of evidence, however weak, during discipline.
In a disciplinary enquiry, hearsay evidence is said to be evidence whose value depends on the credibility of any person other than the one giving such evidence.
It's seen as indirect evidence and so can be unreliable. Because of this potential unreliability, the chairperson must carefully look into the weight that he gives hearsay evidence.
Here are seven rules that you must look into when determining its weight:
The nature of the proceedings;
The nature of the evidence;
The purpose of the evidence;
The probative value of the evidence;
The reason why the witness isn't providing the testimony herself;
Any prejudice towards a party that the evidence might amount to; and
Any other possible factor that can be taken into consideration.
Follow these five steps to ensure you always hold a 100% legally compliant disciplinary hearing
We know you have more important things to do with your time than prove yourself to a guilty employee at the CCMA...
That's why we've made chairing a legally water-tight hearing as easy as five steps.
After having looked at these seven rules, hearsay evidence can be admitted if it believed to be in the best interest of justice.
So there you have it! There are seven rules to follow when considering the value of hearsay evidence.
To learn more, click below…
Protect yourself from labour-related problems by using this practical tool
The comprehensive Labour Law for Managers Loose Leaf Service gives you all the details you need for maximum protection in labour-related problems. You will find, for example:
• Information on the problem areas managers have to handle in the workplace daily, and appropriate solutions;
• Valuable advice for employers, based on the ever-changing legislation;
Sample contracts, dismissals
and warning letters, etc;
• Numerous practical checklists; and
• Much more…