HomeHome SearchSearch MenuMenu Our productsOur products

Eight questions to help ensure your disciplinary hearing is fair

by , 17 August 2016
Eight questions to help ensure your disciplinary hearing is fairAs an employer, there are bound to be employees whose conduct is just not up-to-standard. And so you may wish to dismiss them.

But before you do that, you'll need to hold a disciplinary hearing. What's more is that the entire hearing has to be considered 'fair' according to the law. Because if it isn't, you'll end up in big trouble with the CCMA for an unfair dismissal. And trust me, that's something you don't want.

So to help ensure that your disciplinary hearing is fair, simply answer these eight questions...


Fact: The CCMA doesn't care why you dismissed an employee... It only wants to know if you dismissed him fairly
And if you didn't do it fairly, you could have to pay him up to 12 months' salary! Don't let this happen to you…
Click here for more details…

Eight questions to help ensure your disciplinary hearing is fair


Have you notified the employee of the allegations made against him in the form of a letter? Have you written the letter in a language the employee can reasonably understand? And have you given him at least 48 hours' notice of the disciplinary hearing?


Are you holding the hearing before taking any disciplinary action, so as to give the employee a chance to challenge the evidence before making a final decision?


Have you ensured that the hearing takes place as soon as possible after the incident (preferably no later than 2 to 3 weeks after the incident)?


Have you advised your employee, in writing, of the exact charge you require him to answer, and is it well in advance of the hearing?

Keep reading to see what the other four questions are…


In just 30 minutes you'll find out how to fire an employee fairly and legally!

You have nothing to lose.  Click here now!

Eight questions to help ensure your disciplinary hearing is fair continued…

Is the employee present at the hearing? But if proceed with the hearing without him, is there good reason (for example, he absconded)?


You should the employee to call up witnesses in his defence or in mitigation.


Is the Chairperson neutral? 

To ensure he is, make sure that he:

·         Is in no way involved in the incident that led to the hearing;
·         Wasn't involved in the investigation of the matter;
·         Hasn't been told about the matter;
·         Hasn't had previous conflict with the accused;
·         Has no reason to be biased against the accused;
·         Has adequate skills that are required to chair a disciplinary hearing; and
·         Is not a junior to the Complainant.

If he is biased during the hearing, the employee can challenge the fairness of the hearing, and so even though the law doesn't necessarily require a neutral Chairperson (for example, the owner can be both the complainant and the Chairperson), it's highly advised that you find one as it'll help protect you in case the employee does decide to challenge his impartiality during the hearing.

If he wishes, have you allowed the employee to have the assistance of a trade union representative or a fellow employee to represent him in the disciplinary proceedings? And if the Chairperson says it's alright, have you allowed him to have legal representation?

*If you can answer YES to all of those questions, then your disciplinary hearing will more than likely be considered fair in the eyes of the law.

To learn more on holding a fair disciplinary hearing, page over to Chapter D 01 in your Practical Guide to Human Resources Management handbook.

If you don't already have a copy, click here to order your copy today. 

Vote article

Eight questions to help ensure your disciplinary hearing is fair
Note: 3.84 of 37 votes

Related articles

Related articles

Related Products